How NOT to Make Cornbread
I grew up eating cornbread. It was served as the main course for breakfast slathered in butter and homemade syrup. My mom called it “Johnny Cake” and we loved it!!
Cornbread was on the menu the other day. It was to be served as a side dish with chili.
I always like to work a day ahead (in case of disasters, like I’m about to describe!). It was actually Thanksgiving Day when I was doing the prep work. I had already spent about 3 hours dicing onions, peppers, browning hamburger, etc… and finally the chili was happily simmering away. (Why, oh why, did it take me so long to make chili for 85 people??).
I was pretty tired already, but decided I would quickly get the 3 hotel pans of cornbread baked as well.
I had a recipe scribbled down from a previous cook. Underneath the title, it said, “1 shallow hotel pan (x 2)”. I interpreted that to mean I needed to multiply the recipe by 2 for each shallow hotel pan.
Therefore, for 3 pans, I was using 24 cups cornmeal, 24 cups flour, etc, etc.
After proceeding to throw a mountain of ingredients into the ginormous mixer, I finally got it all mixed and wrestled into the pans. I shut the oven door, set the timer for 20 minutes, and breathed a big sigh of relief.
My work day was almost over.
The cornbread smelled yummy as it was baking, so naively, I thought all was well…
The timer dinged happily away at the appropriate time, but I was in for a surprise when I opened the door.
Although the top was beautiful a golden brown, the underneath was still a mass of undone gooeyness.
Oh, dear.
I spent the next hour checking that cornbread. Turning the oven down. Turning the oven up. Testing it with a toothpick. Testing it with a fork. Oh, mercy.
In the end, it was salvagable…but, not the way it was intended.
What went wrong, you ask??
Well, I shouldn’t have multiplied the batter x2 for each pan. The note must have meant to make 2 pans!! I had actually put enough batter for 6 pans into 3 pans!! Let me tell you, those were some giant pieces of cornbread!!:)
Here is the recipe I should have used for 1 shallow hotel pan:
4 cups cornmeal
4 cups flour
1 cup sugar
4 Tbsp. baking powder
4 tsp. salt
4 eggs
4 cups milk
1 cup melted butter
Bake at 425 degrees for 20 –25 minutes.
Now it’s your turn. Have you ever had any disasters in the kitchen?? (Or am I the only one??)

I used this recipe tonight for my Senior Assisted Living Residents. I like it very much – I used it exactly but used a 4″ hotel pan as I was sure it would rise higher. It came out great. Nice and cakey – I don’t want my Seniors to choke on dry cornbread but they do love it.